Friday, January 15, 2010

From ‘Made in China’ to ‘Owned by China’

Between 2007 and 2008, Chinese overseas investment almost doubled to $52.2bn. In May 2009 the Chinese government announced that Chinese companies would soon find it easier to invest overseas. Just as scary is the fact is that, at the start of May 2009, the IMF reported that China held $1.8 trillion in foreign reserves - which is to say, in convertible foreign currencies, with perhaps 70% of that in US dollars.[1]

This is more than the GDP of Russia – the world’s 8th largest economy - or the total GDPs of all the 140 smallest countries put together. It is also enough to buy the 11 largest non-Chinese corporations outright, including the four largest oil companies, Wal-Mart, GE, Proctor and Gamble, Johnson and Johnson, IBM, and Microsoft. Given that the other four out of the world’s fifteen largest corporations are already Chinese, this suggests that a great deal of attention needs to be paid by anyone expecting a future capitalist global economy to respond to democratically expressed environmental concerns. It is exceedingly unlikely that either China’s own corporations or the non-Chinese companies with whom they compete will be either inclined or in a position to address popular environmental concerns – or needs - in the coming decades.

How many of the world’s hundred to so dominant corporations and conglomerates will end up in with owners from non-democratic countries in the future is difficult to gauge. Probably all of them will have major shareholders from such dubious polities. For governments, resistance to foreign ownership seems to be largely cosmetic, while companies are likely to be equivocal at best. Indeed, at least one of the major banks – Barclays – preferred to raise capital from such sources (in their case a Gulf sovereign wealth fund) rather than accept support from the British government. As a Financial Times commentator put it, ‘As a bank with an increasingly global business, freedom from government meddling was essential’.[2]

One is inclined to ask, how long will such businesses be able to resist meddling from their new friends – and towards what goals will that meddling be directed? In 2009 Chinalco (a Chinese aluminium company) initiated a move to buy a sizeable stake in Rio Tinto (the world’s third-largest mining company, with largely Anglo-Australian ownership), which the Chinese government repeatedly asserted was purely a commercial investment. Yet shortly after the (ultimately unsuccessful) deal was announced, Chinalco’s president was appointed to the State Council - China’s counterpart of the Cabinet. Nor was even the commercial element of this enormous deal at all apolitical. On the contrary:

Four of the biggest state-owned Chinese banks lined up to lend the company
more than it required for its planned second investment. They charged interest
close to zero and did not set a time for Chinalco to pay its debts. Such lending
activity is possible only in China, where state-owned banks and businesses are
treated as the left and right arms of the state, working together to achieve
national long-term development objectives.[3]

Based on this highly politicised strategy, China’s total direct foreign investment has gone from almost nothing at the turn of the millennium to topping $52 billion in 2008. With only a little more expansion, over a ten year period that would equate to buying a half-share in all of the world’s ten largest companies China does not already own.

More generally, the present economic downturn has seen huge acquisitions by funds based in non-democratic countries in companies that Japan, the West and their immediate allies have previously regarded as ‘theirs’. Of course, any notion of national control over transnational corporations has increasingly strained credulity, but I suspect that ceding so much economic power to non-democratic countries will introduce huge new obstacle to those who seek to save the environment for human beings rather than for governments or business.

Of course, the conventions of capitalist economics would regard this is as quite normal. If China has the money to buy then China should be welcomed as the new owner. But capitalism is also only acceptable to most of those who live under it in the west because its enthusiasts claim that it has at least a nominal commitment to a certain style of non-political governance (and conversely a commitment to corporate non-interference in politics), and plainly this would be violated by allowing such politically committed buyers to take such a strong position.

This may seem to contradict one of the general thrusts of this blog: that what is wrong with capitalism, from an environmental perspective, is precisely its lack of political direction. But not all political directions are equal, and China’s track record hardly suggests a wholesome commitment to the interests even of its own people, let alone a sustainable global environment.

[1] http://www.imf.org/external/np/sta/ir/hkg/eng/curhkg.htm#I.
[2] Financial Times, May 7 2009.
[3] Yao (2009).

The lovely Pat Robertson

Pat Robertson, reports today's Guardian, blames the Haiti earthquake on the people of Haiti themselves for making a pact with the devil to gain independence from France in 1804. You can see him saying so on Youtube.

From this we can infer that:

  1. Both Pat Robertson and God are opposed to countries freeing themselves from tyranny. Apparently it takes a pact with the devil to get you free. So who did the American Revolutionaries do a deal with, Pat? And does that mean that you (and God) believe that we Brits should have our American colonies back? Or perhaps that we Brits should hand ourselves (and the USA) back to the Romans? Or ...? (Opened a bit of a can of worms here, Pat.)
  2. Mr Robertson's God is a bit slow on the uptake. The Haitians sign a pact with the devil in 1804 and God punishes them in 2010? Oh all right, they've been ahveing two centuries of hard time, but that only makes the matter worse - not content with punishing the first Haitian revolutionaries, he punishes their children adn their children's children. I assume that Pat would welcome the imprisonment not only of criminals but also their children and their children's children, for century after century. Why do so few Christians seem to have any grasp of morality and responsibility?
  3. President Obama would be wrong to close Guantanamo - this is exactly where vicious lunatics like Pat Robertson belong. But perhaps the base itself could be moved across the strait to Haiti itself, so that this Man of God can be more directly in touch with the suffering people of Haiti - and vice versa, perhaps with a sign around his neck explaining his interesting theological position.

Tuesday, January 05, 2010

Monday, January 04, 2010

How big is the current recession - really?

I've just read Bruce Watson's article 'The Great Recession: A Hidden Depression?' in the Daily Finance. To quote its opening paragraph in full:

The story of the Great Depression is often told in pictures: while few people recognize the names "Smoot-Hawley" or "Schechter Poultry," photographs of bank runs and bread lines continue to pack a punch, almost 80 years after they were first snapped. But the Great Depression's position as our absolute standard for economic disaster carries an unintended consequence: The power of its images seem to overwhelm -- and minimize -- the economic troubles of our own time. After all, if it doesn't look like a Depression, how tough could things be?

As Watson documents in some detail (for the USA), the correct answer is 'very tough indeed'. By the end of 2009, foreclosures had topped 4 million, and 14% of homeowners with mortgages were either in foreclosure or behind on payments. Much the same percentage of the population is homeless, of which about 40% are children. There seems to be little reason to think that the worst is past.

Which is odd. The news programmes I hear are constantly citing how much the stock market has risen by, and by implication, that everything is getting better. Most of the big indices have done pretty well. No news that I am aware of about the real economy, though - you know the economy that produces the goods and services and employs all those people who didn't actually cause this crash but are certainly on the sharp end now. Why the complete lack of interest?

I suspect that the answer is that they're not newsworthy. Not exciting bond traders or investment bankers. No need to worry about them.

On cap and trade

Click on the title of this post for some interesting observations on cap and trade. It can't work unless we force the price of carbon so high that it is uneconomic to burn fossil fuels, and that will never be allowed to happen so long as everyone thinks a) economic benefit can be created while disregarding the environmental consequences, and b) this is a zero sum game in which we have to make someone else pay.

Sunday, January 03, 2010

What makes an economy healthy?

A persistent theme in economic reasoning is to fail to define what is meant by 'the economy', and in particular its conception of economic health. Here are four possible definitions of economic health, of which only the first (and until the recent boom, the second) seems to be taken at all seriously by politicians:

  1. Monetary measures of economic activity such as GDP or profitability. This is essentially a financial view of the economy.
  2. Then there is the definition of economic health based on the so-called real economy. This involves measuring how well we are achieving the creation of the right mix of goods and services to maintain the economic system itself - as measured by growth, profitability, government income from taxation, employment levels, international competitive position, and so on.
  3. Then there are measures of how well the economy contributes to creating a healthy society. This would include measures of human well-being, social solidarity, and so on.
  4. Finally (so far), there are measures of how well the economy contributes to creating a sustainable society. This takes into account society's position in the natural world.

Note that, in Definitions 3 and 4, I say that these measures 'would' be used. It's not that such measures don't exist - on the contrary, we seem to be awash with studies of human happiness these days (a great deal of it summarised in The Spirit Level, by Richard Wilkinson and Kate Pickett 2009). However, such measures have no impact on actual economic management, so they hardly count (yet).

Definitions 1 and 2 - the 'financial' and 'real' economy definitions - look very similar, in that the definition of health itself remains much the same, with only the diagnostic differing much. Yet the differences are fundamental, for when economic health is measured and managed exclusively in terms of money (GDP, profit, and so on), booms will always turn pathological. And that is exactly what we got, of course, as soon as the momentum was dominated by those with no other grasp of the economy than as a device for making money - the investment bankers, the corporations whose profits come primarily from treasury operations, and so on. And of course, our economically naive politicians followed suit - endlessly grovelling to these alleged Masters of the Universe -and so, of course, ensuring that they would indeed be the true masters of our economy.

All the same, measuring economic health in terms of the second, 'real' economy definition of economic health means limiting ourselves to another strictly economic definition. This one is taken from a previous age when the link between the economy and society was not taken for granted and even economists did no believe quite so slavishly in markets, or even profitability, as a measure of economic health. This post-War era was was killed by globalisation, though the final coup de grâce was administered by Thatcher, Reagan, the Chicago School of economics and the Washington Consensus adopted by the IMF, World Trade Organization, World Bank and many national governments.

The strength of the 'real economy' definition of economic health is that it does at least tether the economy to society. Of course, business itself was constantly bucking against it, but fortunately the post-War social consensus was that society needed to be actively managed and the economy was not the same as business. When that ceased to be true - when national economies suddenly found themselves confronted with global competition and national businesses were allowed to shift capital and operations offshore - and big business discovered that it held all the important cards, the post-War social consensus promptly collapsed. The financialisation of the economy followed all but automatically, and the rest is history.

Hence also the weakness of the second, 'real economy' definition of economic health - that it ties the economy to society but does not define it in terms of what it does for society. So although politicians and economists regularly insist on the social connection, this is seldom more than verbal reassurance. Conversely, little attention was paid to what would happen if national economies were internationalised while there was no global consensus, let alone global political apparatus, for managing an increasingly global economy. As usual, the economists (a body of intellectuals blessed with 20:20 hindsight) completely failed to predict what happened next.

So as soon as the circulation of capital and resources starts to enter new circuits, the entire political class was thrown into disarray, excepting only those for whom it was axiomatic that markets should be allowed to determine everything (Thatcher and Reagan) and those for whom capitalism had always been suspect (socialists, etc.). The immediate effects were that everything was sacrificed in the name of an extremely narrow definition of economic health (implicitly Definition 1, of course) - the privatisation and marketisation of the public sector, tax breaks and subsidies for fabulously wealthy corporations and individuals and, far from the economy serving society, coming to see society as being reduced to an appendage to the economy. Happy days indeed.

It was twenty years before the new market/Washington consensus was able to dominate the entire political spectrum (at least as far as parliamentary politics was concerned), but there was never much doubt that it would.

So the second definition of political health was always unstable. As for the third - the creation and maintenance of a healthy society - it never really got a grip on economics. At a rhetorical level, of course, it was always argued, even by the most extreme market enthusiasts, that the full marketisation of the economy would benefit us all. But that merely meant that connection was assumed - the same as definition number two. On the other hand, the actual method chosen to hand it over - handing over society's key assets to big business, deregulating markets, and so on - not only assumed that Definition 3 could be achieved by equating it with Definition 2 but all but made it inevitable that the economy itself would quickly lapse into Definition 1 - the source of our current woes.

But even if Definition 3 could have been enforced by political control over the economy - a doubtful proposition, given the lack of clear understanding by mainstream politicians and economists of how capitalism really works - it is now clear that this would not have been enough. For centuries we have paid little attention to society's impact on nature, even though it has sometimes reached the point where a civilisation has effectively committed environmental suicide.

Nor was this simply a matter of ignorance. We have had the materials for a true environmental science for as long as there has been a science of any kind. Liebig and others were already explaining how we were constantly undermining the natural basis for society in the middle of the nineteenth century. It was not hard to see or understand: you measure some basic facts, such as how much (literal) crap is being poured into the sea instead of being pumped back into the land, that told you how quickly you were depleting the soil, and that told you how long we could go on like this.In economic terms, the problem was that no strictly economic measure of well-being was going to capture society's ultimate sustainability if if did not measure the long-term, inter-generational impact of economic activity.

Basically, economic metrics look equally benignly on social 'bads' and goods, just so long as someone was paid to create them, and ignore both when no one is paid either to create them or clear them up. Nor do they generally take into account how we squander resources, not only using up what should be our children's heritage but even turning what one would have thought were inherently renewable resources such as fresh water and fertile soil and seed into non-renewable resources.

The reason we didn't pay attention to this kind of insight was simple but not obvious. Even while we were creating the science needed to understand just how unsustainable our economic system was, the economic system itself was throwing up both theoretical and practical barriers to understanding this fact. On the one hand, economic theory was claiming that a combination of market-driven efficiency and resource substitution meant that the economy would take care of all these problems automatically, so they did not need to be managed by anyone else, and society could blithely look the other way. On the other, by the time the size of this mistake was clear, we were too committed to an economy that was driven by constant growth to be able to see or admit that we were indeed in deep trouble.

So major studies of the (un)sustainability of the economy start to be published in the nineteen sixties and seventies - Only One Earth, The Limits to Growth, and so on - and here we are, four decades later, still unable to take them in. Rather, the dissonance between any realistic solution to the problems of environmental sustainability and capitalist economic viability have rendered the problem too complex, the forces aligned with the wrong answer too powerful and those charged with solving the problem have been rendered too scared, too confused and too weakly equipped to deal with it.

Monday, December 21, 2009

The Coming Shortage Of All The World's Most Important Industrial Metals

To read André Diederen's deeply scary presentation, 'Metal minerals scarcity and the Elements of Hope' (presented at the ‘Peak’ Summit, Alcatraz, Italy, June 27, 2009 and republished by Business Insider), click on the title of this post.

In essence: all the major metals on which western economies rely will peak within the next few decades. And then... To quote verbatim the conclusion:

  1. Less affordable mass electronic products
  2. Forget large-scale conversion towards alternative energy sources
  3. Forget large-scale electrification of land-based transport
  4. Chemical compounds will become more expensive
  5. Construction and machining will become more expensive
  6. Metals scarcity will aggravate energy scarcity

I think 2, 3 and 6 are quite enough. But there will be no Copenhagen for resource depletion until it is far too late, because all the key resources are owned by corporations or national governments. The USA and EU are especially exposed, and especially exposed to China - an almost equally scary idea.

As for Diederen's proposed solution:

  1. Use less or “managed austerity”
  2. Longer product lifetime
  3. Recycling and reuse of materials
  4. Substitution of materials
  5. Develop adapted new products
  6. Stockpiles

Hard to see how any of this can be achieved under the current economic regime:

  1. Use less or 'managed austerity' - In a production/consumption-driven capitalist economy?
  2. Longer product lifetime - As above.
  3. Recycling and reuse of materials - Possibly, but the maths of exponential growth means this will only put of the peak by a few years. Has no one learned from the Limits to Growth?
  4. Substitution of materials - With what? How often can metallic materials be replaced with non-metallic materials? Sometimes...
  5. Develop adapted new products - OK if these can be made profitable - and do not themselves involve any of the key materials. Hard to imagine.
  6. Stockpiles - Given the above, what will there be left to stockpile?

Finally, the effect of materials shortages and the domination all this hands to undemocratic governments and global corporations will be to undermine the possibility this very solution ever being carried out.

Very few 'elements of hope', I think.

http://www.businessinsider.com/energy-and-mineral-production-on-a-permanent-downward-spiral-2009-12#economies-are-growing-exponentially-which-is-the-root-cause-of-resource-strain-1