Monday, February 08, 2010

A DIY manifesto

Less than 90 days to the General Election, and everything seems a good deal less certain. A year back, a Tory landslide seemed a foregone conclusion and Gordon was indisputably headed for backbench ignominy. How different – and how uncertain – everything seems now.

Well, not quite everything. Mulling over the goods on offer, it’s hard to feel uncertain about one thing: whoever wins, the electorate will be hard pressed to have high expectations of the winner. And in a time of war, economic crisis and unearned wealth for the few and undeserved hardship for millions, that is surely the one thing we cannot afford.

Who should we take to task for this? Our uninspired, uninspiring political masters? The army of unelected, manipulating ‘special advisers’? The abything-but objective and balanced media? No. Democracy is rule of the people, by the people, for the people, so if what We the People are getting isn’t what we want, then We the People have only ourselves to blame.

But there’s the rub. Just how do we change things? The only mechanism on offer is the ballot box, through which ‘we’ supposedly send ‘them’ a ‘signal’ telling them what we think. Only it plainly doesn’t work that way. Maybe they will get the message – and maybe not. And even if they get the signal, they are all too free to interpret it to suit themselves. And while we are limited to the ballot box, it can hardly be otherwise.

So let’s not make the mistake of trying to use the system to fix the system. No, let’s turn the tables completely. Let’s decide that, here in the age of the internet, we can tell them what we want, and decide that the job of politicians is to tell us not what we can have but only how they plan carrying out our orders.

It’s a slightly bonkers idea, of course. To start with, there are plenty of things voters would never agree about in a million years, which leaves plenty of scope for the usual manifesto verbiage. It’s also pretty hard to believe that our media would make it easy for public opinion to be untainted by corporate propaganda and sectional interests.

But that still leaves all those things that plenty of voters agree on – regardless of what the lobbyists persuade politicians to think – but which stay off the political agenda for years and decades together because our political parties can’t – or won’t - fit them in?

So what do voters actually want? I’ve no idea, and it would defeat the whole point to try to decide for them. On the other hand, if anyone would like to set up the website, database and voting system, here is my personal Top 10 (oh, all right, 11) for starters:

Politics

  1. Government ministers and senior civil servants should be forbidden to personally use private health or education. Yes, I know, quite a few ministers sincerely believe in the right to go private, but it’s the public system we pay them to run, and I can’t help feeling that they’d be a little less inclined to treat public services as political footballs if, as their business pals like to say, they had a little more skin in the game. Politicians need to know that, when they cut health budgets, this means them.
  2. The children of all MPs who vote for war are immediately conscripted to the front line. And if, in this age of political babes-in-arms, the MPs themselves if they are 45 or under, off they go too. If a cause is worth having someone else’s kids die for, sacrifice closer to home is surely warranted - and required.
  3. Replace the voting system with one that tells our representatives what we think of them –scores for each candidate – positive or negative - and if the ‘winner’ is the one we think least badly of, so be it. And instant recall if we just don’t think they’re up to it. Enough of ‘respect’ for the ‘authority’ of Parliament: MPs are our employees, and should expect to be fired if they’re not good enough.
  4. And on the voters’ side? Mandatory voting. I haven’t voted in years (who was there to vote for?), but if I were voting for what the people really wanted, what right would I have to keep silent?
The media
  1. Prevent any single individual or company from owning more than one television station or one national newspaper, or both a television station and a national newspaper. Enough of corporate bias and propaganda. (I’d probably extend this to state funding for Private Eye, just to make sure that the mass media also got their fair share of attention, but Ian Hislop would probably rather die than accept.)
  2. Replace the Press Complaints Commission with a truly independent body with real teeth. (And an independent Independent Police Complaints Commission too, while we’re at it.)
Business
  1. Stop business turning schools, hospitals and society’s other key institutions into ‘business opportunities’. There’s little that annoys me more than the commercial prostitution of everything in sight, but when it comes to my children’s education and health, advertising is straightforward pornography. (Banksy has the right idea – if an advertisement is shouting in my face, I have the right of reply – including scribbling all over it if I want. They started it.)
  2. Get serious about corporate crime. Any director of a tobacco company should be tried for manslaughter. Anyone who was still a director after the tobacco companies’ own research showed that tobacco was addictive and poisonous should be tried for murder. As for the advertising agencies, the lobbyists and all the rest who prostituted their talents to help tobacco companies sell their poison, perhaps a little tar and a few feathers? (Could be worse – what I really meant to write there was ‘public stoning’.)
  3. Place much firmer controls on business influence over politics. Business people are people but businesses are not, and are entitled to precisely zero representation in our political system. Put an end to lobbying of political bodies, corporate funding of political parties and all the rest of the sleaze. And if trades unions and other corporate bodies are busy doing this too, include them in the same controls.
The environment
I could go on and on about global warming and climate change, but really, after Copenhagen, does anyone really think any government has any intention of doing what is needed, no matter what the public pressure? Puh-lease…

All the same, how about:
  1. Real public education on climate change. That’s what governments signed up to at Kyoto, but I haven’t seen it yet. Maybe they forgot to read the small print, but meanwhile the nutters and the lobbyists are getting the upper hand.
  2. A serious plan to cut our national carbon footprint. No, we don’t have to wait for the Americans or the Chinese – even if Beijing and Washington won’t help make things right, we can at least minimise just how bad things become.
Perhaps it can’t work – a political nirvana, in which the government of people can be replaced by the administration of things, because, to quote the famous Zapatero slogan, ‘Here the people give the orders and the government obeys’. Well, perhaps it’s all a bit too un-British. But surely we can give them a few polite hints?

Monday, February 01, 2010

How do we pay for micro-generation?

I just wrote a letter to The Guardian. It said:

With the government's new electricity feed-in schemes, surely mortgage lenders could now realistically finance the installation of a nation-wide micro-generation capacity? With a pay-back period of, say, a decade, could they not receive the income from generation until the installation is paid for (at a reasonable ROI), with ownership then reverting to the homeowner? Large financial institutions would be far better at pressing the government for better returns, the homeowner would pay nothing but gain a more valuable property, and the chances of our reaching our current renewables target would be much improved.

I hope they print it. Even more, I hope someone gives the idea some thought.

Friday, January 29, 2010

The problem isn't Peak Oil. It's just plain OIL

It seems to be very hard for some people to 'get' what the problem with fossil fuels really is. Daniel Yergin, Mr Peak-Oil-What-Peak-Oil? in person, is apparently in Davos for the annual jamboree in which all those clever people who got us in the current mess celebrate how clever they are.

Mr Yergin thinks Peak Oil is a long way off. A lot of other people in Davos would agree, I suspect, though whether this is a matter of superior knowledge, judgement or self-interest I would not like to say.

But what does it matter how far away Peak Oil is? Assume that it is close, or has even arrived. The contradiction between falling supply and massively accelerating growth (courtesy of China, India, etc.) will create an equally massive economic crisis. But what if we assume that Peak Oil is far off, as Yergin argues. What then? We syphon billions of barrels of the stuff up the surface and burn it into CO2? Yes, that's exactly what we do.

As various people have now noted, we cannot afford to burn more than a small fraction of even the fossil fuels at our disposal now, let alone any additional future supplies - not because of its economic price but because of its environmental consequences.

So, Peak Oil is a huge problem. But so is the oil continuing to flow.

To put the matter in a nutshell, the problem is not Peak Oil. It's just plain Oil. A uniquely valuable and important commodity, but one for which we haven't even begun to really pay.

Those who cannot remember the past...

Three decades ago, the Carter Administration tried to pass legislation to establish an energy policy for the USA. Writing in Wednesday's FT Energy Source, Philip K. Verleger - then Carter's Director of the Office of Energy Policy at the U.S. Treasury - claims that the current Obama administration hasn't a hope of getting his global warming legislation through. The reasons: arrogance, ignorance of the substantive issues, and failure to recognise the power of pork.

For Verleger the implications are clear, and in the light of recent events in Congress (and Copenhagen, because, whatever the scorn within which Europeans treat US politics, this is by no means a uniquely American problem) I find it hard to disagree. Here are Verleger's closing words:

"Many of the veterans of the Carter battle have quietly exchanged emails and
phone calls as the Obama legislation awaits its fate. The consensus opinions are
these:
  1. None of the people putting the Obama energy policy forward understood the
    problems they would face in Congress.
  2. The bill’s supporters (”greens”) are less aware of history than we were in
    the 1970s, if that is possible.
  3. The legislation’s passage is unlikely absent an outside precipitating
    event.

It will be difficult to take effective action on emissions even when every
American accepts global warming as fact. Concerns regarding economic security
are far greater than those over climate impacts 10 or 20 years in the future.
Tragically, individuals pushing such actions - the representatives of various
NGOs covered in this blog, for example - do not understand history, the concerns
of voters, or the workings of Congress.

The battle is lost."

For those of us for whom the problem of global warming is, as energy was for Carter, the Moral Equivalent of War (MEOW!), it's a depressing insight.

Tax breaks for accelerating Peak Oil

Yesterday's Financial Times includes an article by their Energy Editor, Ed Crooks entitled 'Tax breaks to lure oil and gas sector'. It reported that tax allowances of up to £160m per field will be made for developing an area west of the Shetland Islands that probably includes more than 2 billion barrels of oil.

Tax breaks on oil wells? What sense does this make? Oil companies are some of the richest on the planet, and subsidising them to drill is doubly stupid - in a world fast approaching (passing?) Peak Oil, this is foolish short-termism, and in a world that cannot afford to burn more than a small fraction of its remaining fossil fuels before it trips us into irreversible global warming, paying them extra to make sure it happens is simply bonkers.

So why are they doing it? It's a hard region to develop, so if the UK government wants oil money to continue flowing into the economy, they have to bribe oil companies to bring it here. Hence the tax breaks.

It's a characteristic environmental/resource problem that follows from a) the mass nature of many decision-marking processes (e.g., multiple nations and companies making related decisions in parallel) and b) the absence of effective overarching (e.g., global political or regulatory) systems capable of ensuring that the whole - the net impact of a mass of individually intelligible decisions - does not undermine the interests of us all.

And in this case, that is exactly what is happening: a hundred countries trying to attract investment for the sake of the employment, the tax revenues and the boost to GDP are collectively abandoning the responsibility for handing over a sustainable resource base to future generations and accelerating global warming. A thousand companies, all hungry for investment and struggling to maximise their returns, ravish the planet and resist even the most superficial controls.

But there's nothing unique about the oil industry: we subsidise a huge range of damaging and short-term practices (e.g., airline flights through tax breaks and indifference to 'externalities'). In fact governments and business have been 'managing' the economy between themselves for perhaps as long as there has been an 'economy' to manage. Monopolies, politically inspired subsidies, corruption are the normal practices of all major economies - all delivering short-term gains for state and business that destroy the long term interests of society. All that is new today is that these mechanisms are so powerful and so far of the leash that we are simultaneously creating an unprecedented threat to society's very survival and abandoning every tool we once had to manage such a problem.

Thursday, January 28, 2010

The bad guys and the worse guys

I’m looking for a new job. Yesterday evening, sitting in a local cafĂ©, I shocked my wife by suggesting that I would consider working for an investment bank (in IT, not their signature skullduggery). If you have been reading this blog for any length of time, you may will be as astonished as she was – after all this ranting and raving about the causes of the recent crisis and recession, how could I possibly be thinking of working for such dreadful people! What a hypocrite!

Maybe. But the answer is, the investment banks are indisputably the bad guys, but where are the good guys? Haven’t you ever worked for someone who was doing some good, my wife replied? Someone who treated their staff well and was doing something socially useful (as opposed to the irredeemable social parasitism of the contemporary investment bank)?

Not really, I answered. Well, it’s not that they are all relentlessly evil, but rather that all their benevolence seems to stem from the single-minded desire to maximise profits. And if you had to be nice to people to achieve that, then you were damned well nice to them. And when it becomes more profitable to treat them like dirt, that too will come to pass.

Nor are personnel policies the only issue.

  • Some years ago I was working for a major testing consultancy. It collapsed as a result of the .dotcom debacle. And then the fun began. Within a few months we were hearing fascinating tales about the board being investigated by the FBI and our own ex-CEO being highly sought by some quite undesirable company that wanted a word about their relationship.
  • More recently, I spent some time with a major UK supermarket. Their employees told me that they were pretty good to work for – but as soon as you found out anything about how they exploited their suppliers, you’d realise that this was not out of unqualified benevolence. And so on. It’s the norm – companies are indeed becoming more benevolent, but only a) where they have to, and b) it’s the price they pay for extracting more and more high-level value from the employees – you only give potted plants to the ones who need a comfortable environment in which to work effectively.
  • Or going right back into ancient history, when the creative accounting practices used by Arthur Andersen at Enron came to light, I seem to recall that the reaction of many people in the City was ‘Why couldn’t you do that for us?’
So in a sense they are all the bad guys – that’s what it means to be in business. True, some are truly beyond the pale – the tobacco companies, for example, or arms dealers. But investment bankers? Given how the average company uses its ‘treasury’ operations (i.e., lending cash, buying and selling derivatives, etc.) to boost its profits, they were colluding with Morgan Stanley, Lehman and a rest. They weren’t very clever about it – most of them were caught out – but that doesn’t make them less culpable.

Conversely, the investment bankers aren't breaking the system - on the contrary, they represent its apotheosis.

So perhaps I’m making the wrong distinction – there are bad guys, and there are worse guys. The worse guys seem only to be a little smarter and little more determined than the not-quite-so-bad guys, but fundamentally? I’m not sure I can really tell the difference anymore. I’d love a job with the good guys, but I have no idea who they are.

Wednesday, January 27, 2010

Economy versus environment (Part 94)

Q: What would actually happen if any significant proportion of the population suddenly took it into their head to reduce their environmental impact? A: The economy would collapse.

If you look at the recent recession, it is striking how much damage was done by relatively small changes in GDP. Of the highly developed nations, the UK (among the OECD countries, a middling performer) was so badly hit that it has experienced a loss of a little over 2.5% since the end of 2007. What? 2.5% in two years? A bit over 1% a year? What’s the big deal? Yes, I know, losing 1/80th of my income would not be a good thing in a year, but how can this be enough to do so much damage to an economy?

So what would happen if, say, 20% of the population managed to knock 50% off their environmental impact? Surely that would be an excellent start. Well, from an environmental point of view, perhaps. But if that translated into a 10% fall in consumer spending, where would that leave the economy? Consumer spending represents about 56% of German GDP, 58% of Japan’s GDP, 64% of the UK’s and 72% of the US’s (here). So a 50% fall in spending by 20% of all individuals would cut these economies by somewhere between 5.6% and 7.2% of GDP. In other words, even such a small change by a small minority would reek more economic havoc than the current recession!

So, we all get the environmental bug, and the economy folds. And with it go (as the current recession has also shown) investment in green technology and solutions of all kinds. Not everything, but far too much to support the real greening of industry. On the contrary, investors would be heading for the safe, short-term returns. And governments everywhere would be trying to compensate for the shortfall with new spending – and so shoring up the very economic activity those who had cut their impact had hoped to eliminate.

This isn’t a criticism of taking action, of course. But it is the old revision-versus-revolution problem. If you want only that the system work a bit more benignly, you need only revise the system so that it loses its more unpleasant foibles. But if the problem you are worried about is inherent in the system itself, revision isn’t the answer. The only way to fix systematic problems is to change the system in systematic ways.

That in turn is a political issue. Our politicians are of course firmly committed to growth, but that is not an irreversible condition. But two things are fundamental.

  1. We must develop a credible explanation of this most fatal link between economy and environment, and make it as central a plank of future political discourse and policy-making as growth and consumerism have been since the 1970s.
  2. We must define a programme for migrating our existing economy to a sustainable form. This cannot wait for 'the market' or the actions of private corporations, whose interests will never be to change themselves while there is still money to be made. Governments and local organisations must start to plan the elimination of environmentally destructive economic activity, undo the vicious circle of capital expansion that drives consumerism, obsession economic growth and the disregard of the poor and weak.