Sunday, February 21, 2010

Al Gore, Kurt Vonnegut and the siren voices

At the very start of his 2009 book, Our Choice, Al Gore, Nobel Prize winner and darling of so much of the environmental movement, quotes the message Kurt Vonnegut suggested we should leave behind for any passing aliens who may happen upon the wreckage of planet Earth. ‘Carved in great big letters on a Grand Canyon wall’, it would read:

We probably could have saved ourselves, but were too damned lazy to try very hard… and too damned cheap.
When you have stared at our current environmental problems for long enough and marvelled at how little we seem to be willing to do to save ourselves or our children, it is tempting to go along with Vonnegut. But both he and Gore are wrong. We are not too lazy or too cheap and the solutions on offer from Mr Gore will not solve our problems. Neither the problems we face nor the solutions that will deliver us have much to do with technology or making business and governments account for the true cost of energy, manufacturing, agriculture, transport, etc., mass individual action, or any of the other things Gore advocates. Yet it is in many ways a very good book.

The real problem is not our inability to understand or act upon our present problems. It is rather that we are already committed to another way of doing things that prevents us from taking up any of the credible solutions to our environmental problems. Perhaps it’s worth quoting Aldous Huxley again here:
In the nurseries, … the voices were adapting future demand to future industrial supply. ‘I do love flying’, they whispered, ‘I do love flying, I do love having new clothes, I do love…’
The siren voices of growth, consumption, free markets, entrepreneurship and all the rest are busily pointing us in quite the wrong direction. The resources and system needed to fix our problems are under the control of processes, systems and institutions and in the hands iof nterests that would be completely undone by actually carrying the solution.

So the political powers-that-be, who have spent the last three decades abandoning the idea that the world could be a better place only if it were a different place, would have to perpetrate a genuine revolution to get us onto the right track.

Perhaps the single most important thing is to stop thinking of the problem as primarily reflecting personal selfishness (even of investment bankers). Personal actions are certainly part of both the problem and the solution, but it will only have a peripheral effect so long as we fail to also think of both problem and solution in systemic terms. Vonnegut was writing as a novelist and entitled not to be read too literally. But those who fail to understand the nature of our economic system, and the necessities and pressures it places on individuals, institutions and other systems (e.g., the entire social and political systems) are merely standing on the beach trying to bail out the ocean while the tide is coming in faster and faster.

Remember, Odysseus was forced to listen to the Sirens only because there were no other options open to him. Likewise we have few options that will in any way improve our environmental predicament - unless we change our ship and the ocean we sail. Likewise, even our most venal bankers were only following the system. Given a different system, they might not have had the option of running the ship onto the rocks (oops, different part of the Odyssey).

Saturday, February 20, 2010

Consumerism, 1932

I re-read Aldous Huxley's Brave New World, and what do I find?

In the nurseries, … the voices were adapting future demand to future industrial supply. ‘I do love flying’, they whispered, ‘I do love flying, I do love having new clothes, I do love…’

Thursday, February 18, 2010

Danny Chivers - Poet Laureate for the Environment

If you haven't already heard of him, take a listen to Danny Chivers. His poems on the environment and on business are brilliant, enthralling, funny and biting. He also knows his stuff, being (according to azclimatechange.com) a professional carbon footprinting consultant based in Oxford with two environmental Masters degrees.

For more on Danny, go to his blog, at A Daisy Through Concrete or his MySpace page. Or watch him on YouTube. And buy his new CD. We did, and it's excellent.

Get him to your children's school, to your local climate change event, to your front room. And pay him lots - we need more people like him.

Will the Volcker Rule work? No.

When the last crisis kicked off, organisations such as Goldman Sachs were not banks, and therefore would not have able to request support from the US government had the proposed Volcker Rule been in force then. In fact they weren't able to ask for government help then either.

So how did the US Government respond to the crises at Goldman, Morgan Stanley and the rest? By making them banks, even though they plainly were not. It was a fig leaf, to bend the rules so that they would not fail.

So if, in order to avoid the Volcker Rule, these same organisations ceased to be banks, and if there were a new crises that threatened them, what would the US Government do? Going by the evidence of 2008, they would allow them to be banks again.

What possible good will the Volcker Rule have done then, other than to create an illusion of safety for the government and allowing the investment banks to engage in dangerous activities until things get too hot, at which point they will be rescued just like they were last time?

Fair value? Can free markets ever value the environment?

A basic problem with markets that absolutely must be answered if we are to create an environmentally rational economy is that of deciding how to value things. Valuation failures were a key cause of the recent financial crisis, which stemmed at least in part from the policy of allowing companies to claim that their value was whatever the market would currently bear, including any number of imponderable items that had yet to demonstrate any real value, such as future prices, hypothetical values and debatable projections derived from complex financial models. As part of the general indifference to risk exhibited by regulators and accounting authorities during the last decade or so, this so-called ‘mark-to-market’ or ‘fair value’ approach accounting has been a part of US GAAP since the early 1990s and seems to have all but replaced any notion of intrinsic value. And as if all that were not enough, ‘fair value’ accounting was also central to the Enron scandal.

Mark-to-market is obviously important when it came to buying and selling stocks and shares, but it goes far beyond that. The value of company assets that can be offered as collateral is also the basis for loans, derivatives and other direct and indirect funding. So when a bull market lasts for years on end and prices kept going up regardless of any material value of the companies themselves, smart operators are provided with an environment that favours both massive speculation and spectacular frauds. From the point of view of mark-to-market accounting, a bull market amounts to a universal pyramid scheme: whatever the value of an asset or liability today, we can usually assume that it will be worth more tomorrow, so we can borrow today as though we are more wealthy than we really are.

However, when the dislocations and fantasies this situation naturally engenders go too far, the market will be seized by the bears, and the rapid falls in mark-to-market valuations that follow will mean that previous loans, bonds, asset and liability prices, interest rates and pretty much every other number the markets use will start to go the wrong way for everyone – again regardless of the underlying strengths and weaknesses of individual companies. In a bear market, mark-to-market put the pyramid onto its head, and you would be stupid to lend today, as the collateral that guarantees your loans will almost certainly be worth less – maybe a lot less – tomorrow than it is today. In extremis, markets for many items disappear altogether and the financial sector ground to a halt.

The key problem this presents if markets are to be part of the solution of our environmental problems is that the scope, scale and urgency of those problems mean we cannot allow the kind of fragility and flakiness market economies have exhibited to determine how we invest in the environment. Leaving aside the question of speculators actively manipulating environment-related markets (e.g., greenhouse gas cap-and-trade, offsets, and so on – see the final section of this), we cannot accept the risk of being plunged into years of environmental inactivity or retrenchment simply because markets were unable to value these investments appropriately.

But is there any alternative as far as markets are concerned? Is there any definition of value markets can work with that will always reflect the intrinsic social value of taking action to protect the environment? Are there any accounting principles, valuation methods or other general policies, methods or tools that will ensure that environmental investments are not caught up in speculative frenzies and then dumped as unceremoniously as the global financial system was in 2008-9?

Probably not, or at least not ones that are capable of controlling markets without considerable active intervention and constraint – which is to say, undermines their very nature as markets. After all, how are markets to price things other than in money? How am I to judge a given transaction other than in terms of the profit it offers me (which means strictly in terms of money)? And once all value is reduced to money and the only goal is more money, what other valuation method is there apart from what the market says? In other words, regardless of whether valuing assets and companies in terms of their market price is sensible, it represents what market-based investors wanted to know about a stock, because it predicted what they most wanted to know about their ultimate concern, namely profitability.

In short, the markets know the price of everything and the value of nothing. As this is Oscar Wilde’s definition of a cynic, that seems appropriate enough – the attitude of markets (and perhaps business in general) to the environment is cynical at heart, for the only question they are capable of posing is, How do we make money out of this? Not exactly a responsible attitude.

Actually there is a limit to how far this is true. In a market who basic function is to direct investment in the real economy, prices will still be determined by prices, but these prices will be linked to the material consequences of making real investments - in houses, in MP3 players, in clothes, in a million other goods and services. And that of course is what the economy is for – to ensure that society works. True, the answer is still expressed indirectly, in terms of money, prices and profits, but at least the link to real, non-financial value is there.

Or so it should be, in a socially rational economy. But when the central function of markets is perverted into speculation, and the key question is not how to distribute wealth in society but how to make a quick killing by exploiting changes in price.

But is this a real problem, or merely a theoretical stick with which to beat the markets? Unfortunately it is very, very real. For example, by 2008 the average barrel of oil was being traded 27 times before it was actually delivered for use in the real economy. This certainly contributed to the otherwise inexplicable massive price spike of that year, and is hard to account for in terms of buying oil for use in the real economy. Or again, the Tabb Group consultancy has estimated that mroe than 60% of trades in the US stock markets are controlled by automated systems that are designed to take advantage of tiny price difference within miliseconds of their arising - not really an issue for investors in the real economy. More generally, it has been estimated that perhaps 85% of stock exchange activity is speculative, with only a small minority representing genuine investment.

And so on. All in all, the speculators are clearly in charge, and as a number of scandals and exposés have demonstrated, the manipulation of prices is a fundamental of stock markets.

This is perhaps the fundamental problem of using markets to manage the environment: that markets recognise only prices, and no price generated by a pure market can reflect socially rational value (including environmentally rational values) unless forced to do so – which is the very antithesis of a market price. Markets are like severely autistic children: it’s not hard to get through to them - it’s impossible. You can constrain them with regulations and rules, but once the market has taken over control of prices, it is hard to see why just this sort of bubble should not develop.

So can markets play any part in managing the environment? Perhaps in limited ways. But the tendency to break the link with real environmental goals and consequences seems to be intrinsic to any system that measures success strictly in terms of prices and profits. If it doesn’t do that, is it a market? If it does, how can we ever trust it not to undermine every strategy for managing the environment?

Wednesday, February 17, 2010

Yesterday the Financial Times reported that many wealthy countries have failed to fulfil their aid pledges, given only a few years back at the G8 summit at Gleneagles (‘Wealthy countries fail to hit aid target’, FT 17/02/10).

‘The Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development … publishes a report on Wednesday predicting that its rich member countries will collectively give a net $107bn in aid this year... But promises made in 2005 … implied a pledge of almost $130bn by this time.’
No one familiar with the sorry history of aid can be much surprised at this outcome: we practically never do do what we promise, we take back most of what we give, and people die as a result. In fact it is more surprising that we got so close to our targets, and that so many countries are likely to fulfil their individual commitments.

More interesting was the reaction of Max Lawson of campaign Oxfam, who is quoted as saying that: ‘This is a damning indictment of rich nations, who can find plenty of money to save banks but precious little to save lives’.

Obvious enough, of course. But in what sense is this really a ‘damning indictment’? Why have governments found it so easy (relatively speaking) to save the bankers and not the poor? Is it because they are so callow that their priorities are utterly wrong-headed? Quite possibly, and we should not doubt the extent to which the largesse to bankers was the product of very deliberate political manipulation (on which, see Matt Taibbi’s excellent articles here and here).

But that does not explain why the response was quite so immediate and unqualified. That takes us to the question of the relative roles played in our own societies of aid and the banks. Aid is still perceived as a matter of charity, whereas the banking system is the very core of the global economy. If we disregard the interests of the global poor and of under-developed countries, the results are likely to be seen as ‘regrettable’; but if our banking system falls, that takes the economy with it, and the economy is the system through which we produce, distribution, exchange and consume pretty much everything we need to do anything at all – from our daily bread to all that aid, of course.

Yet it is by no means obvious that this is the full answer. In particular:


  1. Why is it that the centre of ‘the system’ lies in finance, which produces only money, and not the ‘real’ economy, which produces the goods and services needed to actually do anything for real people?

  2. The phrase ‘the system’ implies a neutral mechanism that somehow serves us all – as does the way I described it above. But is the economy really neutral, even at that level? Or does it in fact serve on be special set of interests, even when apparently just going about its day-to-day operations?
Answer these questions and a completely different picture emerges – a picture that makes it clear not only that we will never address the problems of developing countries with any sincerity but also that that very economic system will worsen the economic and environmental plight not only of the global poor and of under-developed countries but, in quite short order, the rest of us too.